Skip to main content

Compare reviews and record a panel decision

The panel pack groups completed evaluations for one application response version and its published form version. It lets adjudicators compare independent assessments before recording a separate panel recommendation and outcome.

Open the Adjudication preview.

1. Open a case from the panel queue​

  1. Open the Adjudication centre.
  2. Under Cases to review, choose All cases, Awaiting panel or Decision recorded.
  3. Select the intended case.
  4. Check the application reference, title, organisation and sector.
  5. Confirm the application response and form version in the case summary.
  6. Review the active assignment and submitted review counts before comparing evidence.

If a case is not in the queue, at least one currently active assignment for that exact response version may still be outstanding, a submission may not match its original assignment, or the published form/rubric version may be inconsistent.

2. Compare the completed evaluator assessments​

The Evaluator comparison section is a read-only table with one column for each submitted evaluator and a mean column.

For each criterion, the table shows:

  • criterion title;
  • configured percentage weight;
  • each evaluator's score against the pinned score guide; and
  • arithmetic mean of the individual criterion scores.

Below the table, Evaluator recommendations shows each reviewer's overall recommendation and submission date. Evaluator evidence and rationale presents each submitted overall rationale. Expand View criterion-level rationales to read the original evidence explanation for each criterion.

The case summary separately displays the Mean indicative score. This is the arithmetic average of the evaluators' submitted weighted scores, calculated using the pinned rubric weights and score guide.

Use the comparison to identify agreement, differences in how evidence was interpreted and issues that need panel discussion. Consider the underlying rationales alongside score differences; do not make a decision from the average alone.

The original evaluator submissions are read-only. Do not edit a source score, replace a rationale or write the panel conclusion into an individual evaluation.

Rubric and ranking boundary

The comparison uses the rubric snapshot attached to the completed assessments. When the illustrative fallback rubric is in use, weights and weighted means are prototype values, not an approved CEDA scoring framework, eligibility test or funding ranking.

3. Complete the adjudicator conflict declaration​

In Recommendation and decision, find Adjudicator conflict declaration. Choose the value that reflects the adjudicator's position before recording the panel decision.

A panel decision can be saved only when the declaration is No conflict. Not declared, Potential conflict and Conflict declared all block saving.

If a potential or declared conflict exists, stop the decision process and follow CEDA's approved panel conflict and recusal procedure. Do not change the selector to No conflict merely to bypass the validation. The preview does not maintain a panel roster, assign a replacement adjudicator or process a formal recusal.

4. Distinguish panel recommendation from final outcome​

Complete both fields. They represent different parts of the panel record.

Panel recommendation options:

  • Advance to next stage
  • Request clarification
  • Do not advance
  • Defer decision

Final adjudication outcome options:

  • Pending
  • Selected
  • Not selected
  • Clarification required
  • Deferred

A recommendation is not the same as the final outcome. The panel must record both according to its approved authority and deliberation. The preview does not enforce a mapping between a recommendation and an outcome; explain any material difference in the decision rationale.

Do not interpret Selected as an approved funding award. Authorised CEDA funding approval remains a separate step outside this preview.

5. Write the decision rationale and panel notes​

  1. Enter Decision rationale with at least 80 characters.
  2. Explain the evidence considered, material strengths and risks, how differences between reviews were addressed and why the outcome is justified.
  3. Add Panel deliberation notes for the internal panel record, including discussion points, conditions or reservations.
  4. Use Dissenting or differing view to preserve a material contrary view without overwriting independent evaluations. This field is optional.

The preview requires a panel recommendation, a non-pending outcome, a No conflict declaration and a decision rationale of at least 80 characters before saving.

6. Record an amendment​

After the first decision event exists, the form displays Reason for amending this decision. Enter an explanation before saving another decision snapshot.

The preview appends a history event containing the recorded date, outcome, recommendation, decision rationale and amendment reason. The event history is local browser data, not an immutable or authoritative audit trail. Panel notes, dissent, applicant feedback and session details remain in the current working record; they are not captured as a full versioned snapshot of every field.

The current preview allows the panel working record to be edited. Retain the approved decision and amendment process outside the prototype for any real CEDA work.

7. Separate applicant feedback from confidential deliberation​

The Applicant-facing feedback gate is a separate part of the form.

  1. Enter only constructive text intended for a future applicant communication in Feedback for applicant.
  2. Keep internal discussion, evaluator rationales, dissent and confidential panel details out of this field.
  3. Review the proposed feedback through the required approval process.
  4. Select Mark this feedback as approved for authorised release only when that check has occurred.
  5. Save the decision snapshot.

When the approval checkbox is selected, the preview requires at least 60 characters of feedback. The checkbox records a local approval flag only. It does not publish the text, send an email, notify the applicant or grant official release authority. An unchecked feedback draft can be saved as part of the local working record.

8. Understand the application workflow update​

When a panel decision snapshot is saved, the preview writes a version-linked workflow status for that exact application response and form version:

  • Selected: panel outcome recorded; authorised CEDA funding approval still pending.
  • Not selected: panel outcome recorded; authorised CEDA communication still pending.
  • Clarification required: moves the sample application to the Clarification stage and marks the decision stage as the resume stage.
  • Deferred: records the panel outcome as deferred.

This updates the browser-local application workflow feed. It does not issue an offer, decline letter, funding approval, payment or applicant notification.

Continue with Review sessions and decision history.