Skip to main content

Assess and submit an evaluation

Once a clear No conflict declaration is recorded, the evaluator can assess the assigned application response version using the rubric snapshot attached to that assignment.

Open the Evaluator preview.

1. Review the application evidence​

  1. Open the assigned review from Assigned reviews.
  2. Confirm the application reference, organisation, application response version and published form version.
  3. Read the Proposal summary.
  4. Review the submitted answers by form section. The answer fields are read-only.
  5. Open Supporting documents and read each document requirement and applicant instruction.
  6. Review the attachment filename, type, size and upload date.
  7. Where a file is available, select Download assigned file.

The preview offers only attachments linked to that assignment and exact response version. File bytes remain in the current browser's local IndexedDB store; they are not retrieved from CEDA production records or a shared document repository. A legacy filename label without an attachment is not a downloadable file.

2. Use the rubric version pinned to the assignment​

The rubric heading identifies either Published Rulebook vX or Illustrative Default Rubric v0.

  • A published rulebook snapshot remains attached to the assignment even when Operations later publishes a newer rulebook.
  • Additional assignments for the same application response and form version retain the same available rubric snapshot.
  • If no Innovation Rules version was published when the first assignment for that response version was created, the fallback rubric is illustrative only and is not an approved CEDA scoring framework.

The default example has six criteria:

CriterionIllustrative weight
Problem significance and beneficiary need15%
Innovation value and differentiation20%
Technical and implementation feasibility15%
Market demand and commercial viability20%
Promoter and management capability10%
Economic contribution and sustainability20%
Total100%

The default five-point guide is 1 Weak, 2 Limited, 3 Adequate, 4 Strong and 5 Exceptional. A published rubric may replace the default criteria, descriptions, weights and score labels.

Illustrative scoring only

The fallback criteria, weights, score scale and calculated weighted score are prototype values. They are not official CEDA assessment criteria, an approved funding ranking or a funding recommendation policy. CEDA must approve the operative rulebook and assessment framework.

3. Complete the criterion-by-criterion assessment​

For every criterion card:

  1. Read the criterion title and evaluation description.
  2. Note the percentage weight shown on the card.
  3. Select the score that best reflects the evidence in the assigned submission.
  4. Read the label and descriptor for the selected score.
  5. Enter an Evidence and rationale explanation for the score.
  6. Record material strengths, weaknesses, gaps and assumptions rather than relying on unsupported impressions.
  7. Repeat for every criterion in the pinned rubric.

The score choices use the pinned five-point guide. The preview calculates a weighted contribution for each criterion and an indicative score out of 100. The side panel shows the number and percentage of criteria scored.

The calculation normalises each criterion score against the maximum score in the pinned guide and applies the criterion's percentage weight. It is a decision-support display for testing the interface, not an official ranking.

4. Complete the overall assessment​

Under Overall assessment:

  1. Select a Recommendation:
    • Strongly recommend
    • Recommend
    • Revisit
    • Do not recommend
  2. Complete Overall rationale.
  3. Summarise the proposal's strongest evidence, material risks, necessary conditions or improvements, and the reasons for the recommendation.

The overall rationale must contain at least 60 characters. The preview also requires an evidence rationale of at least 20 characters for every criterion before final submission.

5. Save an assessment draft​

  1. Select Save draft below the assessment form.
  2. Read the confirmation notice.
  3. Return to Assigned reviews and confirm that the assignment is marked In progress.
  4. Switch to another preview evaluator identity, then return to the original identity.
  5. Confirm that the draft remains associated with the original preview identity.

Changes are written to browser storage as the form is edited. Selecting Save draft also sets the explicit draft timestamp used by the queue's In progress filter and workload count. A draft is not submitted to Operations or Adjudication.

Drafts are browser-local and evaluator-specific. They are not a shared authoritative CEDA assessment record and are not protected from another person using the same browser profile.

6. Check the final-submission requirements​

Before submission, the preview checks that:

  • the conflict declaration is No conflict;
  • every criterion has a score;
  • every criterion has an evidence rationale of at least 20 characters;
  • an overall recommendation is selected; and
  • the overall rationale contains at least 60 characters.

Select Submit final evaluation to run these checks. Any issues appear in the Before you submit panel. Correct each item and submit again.

The submission button remains unavailable while the conflict declaration is not clear.

7. Review and confirm the final submission​

When validation passes, the Submit this evaluation? confirmation dialog opens. It summarises the application reference and title, response/form version, evaluator identity, recommendation and the illustrative weighted score.

  1. Read the application and response-version details again.
  2. Select Return to review if you need to change any answer.
  3. Otherwise select Confirm preview submission.
  4. Wait for the confirmation notice.
  5. Confirm the queue status is Submitted and the review displays Final evaluation locked.

A final evaluation cannot be overwritten from the Evaluator workspace. The assessment becomes read-only for that preview assignment.

8. Understand what happens after submission​

The final assessment is written to the same-browser completed-assessment register and the evaluator's local archive. Operations can read assignment completion progress and conflict metadata without seeing the criterion scores or rationales.

The application workflow status is updated for the exact application response and form version:

  • while other active assignments for that response remain outstanding, the status indicates independent assessment progress and the completed count;
  • when all active assignments for that exact response/form version have submitted, the application moves to the funding-decision review stage for Adjudication.

Adjudication receives the assessment details through its separate preview workspace after the assigned reviews have been completed. A final preview assessment is not an official CEDA appraisal, approval or funding decision.

9. Understand the preview boundary​

The assignment, draft, conflict and completion registers are stored in this browser. The evaluator identity selector is not sign-in, and there is no production confidentiality boundary between people who can access the same browser profile.

Production use requires CEDA-approved evaluator identity, server-side assignment authorisation, private evidence storage, formal conflict/recusal procedures, durable assessment records, append-only audit, controlled adjudication and decision governance.