Skip to main content

Evaluator assignment and conflicts

An evaluator assignment identifies the exact applicant response version to be assessed. It is not a general permission to browse the applicant register and it does not authorise an evaluator to select their own work.

Open the Evaluator preview.

1. Understand the assignment record​

Operations creates an assignment after an applicant has submitted a response. The assignment is linked to:

  • the application and funding intake;
  • the exact application response version;
  • the published form version used for that response;
  • the selected evaluator preview identity;
  • the assignment date and review due date;
  • the rubric snapshot attached to the assignment; and
  • an active or revoked assignment state.

A later applicant response does not silently replace the response version already assigned. Operations can create a separate assignment for a later version where appropriate.

2. Prepare a synthetic assignment in Operations​

A reviewer cannot create their own assignment in the Evaluator workspace. To prepare a demonstration assignment:

  1. Submit a synthetic funding enquiry through the Applicant workspace.
  2. Open the relevant funding intake in Operations.
  3. Select Evaluator assignments.
  4. Under New allocation — Assign a submitted response, choose the submitted application.
  5. Select the Exact response version to be assessed.
  6. Select one of the preview evaluator identities.
  7. Set the Review due date.
  8. Read the Version-pinned scope notice.
  9. Select Assign selected evaluator.
  10. Confirm the new assignment appears in Assigned response versions.

Draft applications are excluded. If no submitted application appears, first submit a synthetic Applicant response. If the selected response version cannot be matched to its published form snapshot, the preview refuses to create the assignment.

3. Open and verify the assigned version​

  1. Open the Evaluator workspace.
  2. Select the same Preview evaluator identity chosen by Operations.
  3. Find the assignment in Assigned reviews.
  4. Select the queue card.
  5. Check the application reference and title.
  6. Confirm the application ID, response version and published form version in the review header.
  7. Read the proposal summary and the submitted application answers.

The application answers are read-only. Section titles, descriptions and field labels come from the published form snapshot associated with the assigned version.

If an assignment does not appear, check that it is still active, that the same evaluator identity is selected, and that the corresponding response and form snapshot remain available in this browser.

4. Review supporting documents​

The Supporting documents section lists the document requirements from the assigned form version. Each requirement includes its title, applicant instructions and required/optional label.

Where the assigned response version contains an uploaded attachment, the card shows the filename, file type, size and upload date, with a Download assigned file action.

The preview checks that the file belongs to the selected application and document requirement before offering it for download. The file bytes are read from the current browser's local IndexedDB store. A filename-only legacy record is identified as a label; it does not contain downloadable file contents.

A missing required attachment is displayed as No file was attached to this response version. Do not substitute a file from a different application version.

5. Declare a conflict of interest before scoring​

Find Conflict-of-interest declaration and review the declaration prompt. The Your declaration selector offers:

DeclarationPreview behaviour
Not declaredThe assessment form remains locked until a declaration is made
No conflictThe scoring form becomes available
Potential conflictScoring is paused and the declaration is sent to the same-browser Operations conflict-notice register
Conflict declaredScoring is paused and the declaration is sent to the same-browser Operations conflict-notice register

Select the value that accurately represents the synthetic test case. Continue to scoring only when No conflict is recorded.

6. Understand conflict escalation and reassignment​

When Potential conflict or Conflict declared is selected:

  • the assessment form remains locked;
  • the declaration selector becomes locked and the evaluator cannot clear the escalation themselves;
  • a version-linked conflict record is written to the current browser's Operations notice register;
  • Operations can review the conflict status and the assigned evaluator; and
  • Operations must revoke the assignment and allocate that response version to another evaluator after reviewing the disclosure.

A conflict record is status metadata, not a formal conflict investigation. The preview does not send email or external notifications and does not decide whether the conflict is substantiated.

The Operations user must enter a withdrawal reason of at least 10 characters before selecting Revoke access. The revoked assignment is removed from the active evaluator queue on refresh or the next storage update. Operations can then create an assignment for another evaluator.

Do not try to clear a potential or declared conflict by changing the selector back to No conflict. The control is intentionally locked after escalation.

7. Respect version, identity and rubric boundaries​

The preview prevents a duplicate active assignment for the same evaluator, application and response version. It also prevents a completed response version from being assigned again to the same evaluator preview identity.

Assessment drafts are stored separately for each selected preview identity. For a given application response and form version, the first available rubric snapshot is retained for subsequent assignments to that same response version. Later changes to Innovation Rules must not silently change the assessment model already attached to that version.

These are same-browser prototype controls. They are not authentication, server-side access control, a formal recusal register or a guarantee of confidentiality.

Continue with Assess and submit an evaluation.